Indivisible by Daniel Aleman

I received a free copy of Indivisible thanks to The Novl in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are solely my own.

In this book, we follow Mateo Garcia, a junior in high school whose parents have been taken by Immigration officers. Left to take care of his seven-year-old sister, Sophie, and the family bodega, Mateo has to face the impending reality of his parents possible deportation, and is facing tough decisions. More importantly, he’s left questioning everything he thought he ever knew. How can he make sense of this shame he suddenly feels? Why does he feel like an outsider? What does it truly mean to be an American? 

This is such an impactful and unputdownable read. I devoured this in one day—I just had to know what happened. I know that Mateo and his family’s journey will stay with me for a while.

Indivisible is such an important and timely read. So much of it is thought-provoking and should be used for discussions on what it means to be an American or “legal” citizen. As a History Major, this book particularly resounded with me because I’ve always felt passionately about the debate between legal vs illegal immigrants and the reasons why people come to our nation seeking refuge.

Indivisible: My Thoughts

Aleman did an excellent job describing the feelings that Mateo had when he first found out about his parents detainment. He described the shame he felt, anger, disbelief, and isolation. Aleman continued to describe these feelings throughout the book, and those of the other characters, particularly Sophie’s, as they moved through the process of possible deportation and beyond. He shows the ignorance of those around the Garcias, the prejudiced sentiments, and the fear that the whole Garcia family lives with as they wait to find out what will happen with Ma and Pa Garcia. 

There were a couple of things in the book that gave me pause. I was a little surprised when Mateo and Sophie were able to stay by themselves for so long after their parents were detained. I was surprised that the adults in their life just let that happen. Another part was when Mateo’s friends were so dense and kept making everything about themselves.

This book is so important to read because it gives deportation a face. As Mateo says during Pa’s hearing: (quote is from the ARC, may change upon publication) “When you talk about illegal immigrants, you see faceless people in your mind… You see people with no hearts, with no voices. You see them as an evil force, which is just here to take something from you.” This was such an important part of the story for me because I feel like people forget that “illegal” immigrants are people too. They forget that they came to our country for a reason, for opportunity, for refuge, for any number of reasons. 

Overall, this book was such a good read. It was my first 5 star read of the year. I encourage y’all to pick it up. Publication is set for May 2021.

Indivisible by Daniel Aleman

A Shot At Normal by Marisa Reichardt

I received a free e-ARC of A Shot At Normal thanks to NetGalley and Farrar, Straus and Giroux (BYR) in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are solely my own.

The synopsis for this book hooked me the very first time I read it. This book is very timely and poignant. The subject matter of the book, to vaccinate or not vaccinate, is considered controversial, but I think if it’s executed well, it can make for good discussion and thought.

As a mom, I read this with a different perspective because I was able to think about myself in Juniper’s position, as well as her parents’s position. Because of this, I think this personal experience made the reading experience more unique.

A Shot at Normal: My Take

I liked how Reichardt showed the internal struggle that Juniper was dealing with. We know how badly Juniper feels about the measles and the outcome of that, and her vehemence on wanting to be vaccinated. But we also see her grappling with the possible consequences of getting vaccinated and what that would mean for her relationship with her family.

There were a few things that I thought could have been executed better. The relationships in the book all felt like insta-love. Her relationship with Nico, her friendship with Tess, etc. They met Juniper and instantly they were best friends or perfect for each other. It just didn’t feel authentic for me. I also wish the behavior of Juniper’s parents was discussed. They ignored Juniper when they found out she was petitioning them for vaccine rights. I just wish that the behavior had been discussed with perhaps Nico’s mom or Mimi or someone. It was unhealthy.

One aspect of the book that was challenging and I think could potentially be problematic for younger readers (I’m an adult reading YA) was that the argument Juniper’s parents made against vaccines evoked too much sympathy and it did make you feel like maybe it wasn’t so bad.

Overall this was an interesting read. I enjoy reading about controversial subjects and I got that with A Shot At Normal. If you’re looking for a book that touches on the vaccine vs anti-vaccine debate, this is for you!

A Shot at Normal by Marisa Reichardt